Notes from a Newbie
October 10, 2011 by Jessie Gunderson
Filed under Blog, Notes from A Newbie
I remember the day I started seriously writing. It came at the hand of a hard critique. But not just any hard critique, the careful critique of a true mentor and friend. She graciously agreed to take a look at my writing project and give me her thoughts. I’d started writing a testimony of sorts, on my life, fiction style. Or so I thought.
This author wrote me back. Before uttering a word, I knew she’d think my writing was grand.
“Jessie, do you want me to do a full critique on this selection even if it’s tough? Or is this near and dear enough to your heart that you want me to lie to ya’ baby?”
My heart did a little studder step as I felt the sweat tickling down my neck. I hadn’t expected that. More like, “Gee you’ve got talent,” not because I’m really that arrogant. But I’d heard it before from teachers and friends.
I really thought on this one because suddenly I didn’t feel so confident. That story was my baby, the first “real” story I’d tried to write. I had awards from short stories and my sister had convinced me to start a blog but this WIP was about me.
I took a deep breath before typing my reply.
Would she say I had no talent and should forget about quitting my day job. Mom. Okay, I didn’t want to quit even then. I truly thought that you either had the talent or you didn’t. You could write a good book and engage people or you couldn’t and I feared the latter.
Break it to me soft. I wrote. If it is something I can learn, I’m all for it but if I just plain stink, break it to me soft.
She wrote back and to my surprise, assured me it could be learned. Studying the craft of writing would take time, commitment and years of work, but it most certainly could be done.
Thank goodness she took the time to tell me because I could have spent a year on my first sorry attempts at writing, sped off to the first writing conference I could find, pitched my immature scribbling and found that it didn’t measure up. I would have known I had no talent and I would have rolled up my scrolls and stuck to journal writing for the rest of my life, but she taught me it’s more than raw talent it’s work.
I’m still working and since my day job is Mom, I keep getting interrupted by little monsters who do things like crush peanut shells into my rug! But at least I can press on eager to learn and soak up all I can for a day when I’m not quite as interrupted.







[...] Won’t you click here and leave a comment? While you are there, subscribe and keep your eye out for me in the future. Writer Interrupted is a great community of writers who are…well…interrupted. You know who you are! [...]
Truth in love…. It's always best. I enjoy your writing! Thank you for sharing your humble beginnings with us!
Thank you Lisa!
In trying to support new writers, I often buy their books. I tell ya' what, some of them should have a friend like yours! Reading uncritiqued writing, especially published, is PAINFUL! Then I dread when they ask, "What do you think?" What I think is they should have asked for opinions before they published.
I'm glad you see critiquing is to make your baby GROW and become the adult it needs to be.
There are many of us who are excited about your writing potential, Jess! Of course, we expect autographed copies when that WIP is critiqued AND published.
Thanks Mindy! You are sweet.
If I'd known I would shelf that "baby", not sure I would have done it but sometimes you just have to trust.
I'm glad I did.
I'm guessing no matter how long one writes, crits are always hard to take.
Um yes, and I'm getting a taste of my own medicine right now! Vile, nasty stuff!
Oh gosh Cheryl, that's for sure. Its such a hard thing. The arts are a PART of you and who wants someone telling you it doesn't work for them. It's like them saying, "I hate that brown hair you have."
Then we have the trouble of trying to decide if that natural brown really doesn't fit us. We change it and cut it and someone else says, "Gee that color looks fake!" ACK! Then what? Vicious cycle.
Thanks for the encouragement Jan!
AND thanks Gina Conroy for that hard crit and for helping "launch" my career.
We all feel your pain, Jessie. It's hard to hear the critique on your first serious work. I heard someone say the other day that we should never think of our WIP as our baby. We tend to hold it too close. You are a good writer and a good learner!
Jan